Rascal
One loses sense of time in the woods. I had no watch to replace my broken Ingersoll and could only guess at the hour of the day by looking at the sun. I had even forgotten what day it was–and it certainly didn’t matter. No schoolbell or churchbell rang to remind us of the dutiful passage of time. One day blended into the next and could only be remembered as the day we saw the porcupine or the day we found Lost Lake. (91)
This aspect of the book reminds me a lot of The Trumpet of the Swan and nature-loving Sam Beaver (linked to my review). There is a good bit of natural history mentioned in the book, and some of it is evolutionary in nature. (I offer this as a “heads up” to anyone who might offer this to a child and find this problematic.) Sterling mentions that his mother is the one who taught him about the origins of the earth and that she reconciled this scientific explanation with the Biblical creation account. Although this matter is something Steady Eddie and I definitely want to study, discuss, and explore with our girls, I didn’t feel that our read-aloud time was the right time to begin the process, so I creatively edited this part. (I have no qualms about censoring materials on-the-fly as I’m reading to my girls if I come across something that is inappropriate.) I had another near-miss when Sterling mentions that his new teacher discussed the “facts of life” with his class. Again, this is not a subject I intend to skirt with the girls, but I didn’t feel the time was right for it, so I ended the session a little early.
Rascal is by far the most difficult book I’ve read to my girls, and at times I wondered if I had the tenacity to finish reading it aloud to them, but they’re funny that way–they won’t let me stop reading a story once we’ve begun it, no matter how much I doubt their involvement in it. Even with the aforementioned little episodes (and my editing), though, I think my girls really enjoyed this story. My used copy of the book has a handwritten notation inside the front cover that it is at a 7.9 reading level. (I’m guessing this is an Accelerated Reader level.) I think it would take a voracious seventh grader reader to persevere through the story alone, but for the nature or animal loving child, I don’t doubt that it would be worth it. Rascal won a Newbery honor in 1964. The story was also made into a movie, but I haven’t seen it. Does anyone care to weigh in on the movie version?
We’ve moved on to lighter fare this week, and while I’m glad to have closed the cover on Rascal for now, I’m equally as glad that we read it. What about your and your family? What are you enjoying these days? Link up your Read Aloud Thursday post in the comments.
This we looked at “two monsters” – a story about different points of view – http://www.redtedart.com/2011/05/04/kids-get-crafty-loo-roll-monsters/
Maggy x
That sounds like a really cool book!
We mostly focused on Forests this week, but not totally:
http://thelintonacademy.blogspot.com/2011/05/current-read-alouds.html
Thanks!
RockerMom
Rascal is one I’ve never read but always had on the radar to read one day. I think both my boys would enjoy it.
I wrote about books about rabbits this week.
http://supratentorial.wordpress.com/2011/05/05/read-aloud-thursday-rabbits/
Loved getting your thoughts on this! I read it in 6th grade and loved it. We watched the movie a few weeks back, but I didn’t remember enough about the book to compare. I’m sure it took some liberties, and it didn’t include either of the passages you mention “editing.”
There’s an abridged version that my daughter read. I didn’t screen it myself, but now I’m curious…
We finished Caddie Woodlawn, and I’m linking up here:
http://www.acrossthepage.net/2011/05/05/caddie-woodlawn/
Hope you don’t mind if we join you Read Aloud Thursday!!
http://busy-homeschool-days.blogspot.com/2011/05/read-aloud-thursday-wizard-of-oz.html
Great review of an excellent book! I’ve seen the movie, and as far as I can remember, my family enjoyed it. However, it’s been a while, so I don’t really recall how true it stayed to the original story.
Ink Slinger–thanks for weighing in in the movie. Thanks for clicking over to my blog this weekend!
I red Rascal so long ago that I don’t remember much about it. Some books are more challenging to read aloud. Right now I’m reading Joni to a nine year old, twlve year old and a fourteen year old. I think some of the subject matter is a little too much for the nine year old, but she’s the one who wants to keep reading when we’ve finished for the day.
I read this book many times as a child and trace my continued love for raccoons to Sterling North’s wonderful account of his pet coon and the incredible drawings found in this fine book.
So this year I give the book to me 7 year old niece and we read it together. I was shocked to find evolution being taught and even one occurrence of the D word! I didn’t remember anything like that ever … but there it was. I smoothed it over but I may be a little less eager to recommend this book in the future. That makes me sad because it’s a wonderful book … but there are certainly some places one needs to be careful with.
I’ve just finished reading Rascal for the first time. I teach 4th grade and was considering it for a lit. group, particularly because of the multitude of animal adaptation and behavior references. They tie in so wonderfully with our science. Having finished it, I realize it is too lofty for them to read independently so I will use it as a read aloud.
Though I respect the opinions about the difficult topics addressed, I plan to read the book with all parts (yes, including the “d” word) to preserve the author’s words. I prepare my students by discussing the author’s purpose for authenticity in telling the story. If a child already knows it’s a bad word (and they all do), then he knows not to repeat it. Just as the character comes to his own realization about trapping animals, it is through education that we grow and come to our own conclusions.
I’ve written all kinds of notes to myself in my copy and cannot wait to read it to my kids. I think they’re going to love it as much as I do.
Heather,
In general I am not in favor of censoring an author’s original words. However, since my children are very young (just 8 and 6 now, so they were much younger when I read Rascal aloud to them), I tend to err on the side of caution. Now that I also have a two year old listening along, I am even more cautious, for while they would understand that a word is “bad,” he would not. Certainly your situation with a classroom full of age-mates might be looked at differently. Thank you for commenting and I hope your school year goes smoothly and successfully!